| # | Sires | Starters | Winners | SWs | Win % | Earnings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Into Mischief | 432 | 229 | — | 53% | $24,304,799 |
| 2 | Gun Runner | 227 | 125 | — | 55% | $16,992,292 |
| 3 | Twirling Candy | 263 | 149 | — | 57% | $14,841,744 |
| 4 | Constitution | 285 | 142 | — | 50% | $14,397,008 |
| 5 | Uncle Mo | 274 | 137 | — | 50% | $13,838,798 |
| 6 | Munnings | 328 | 180 | — | 55% | $13,401,020 |
| 7 | Practical Joke | 300 | 154 | — | 51% | $13,358,085 |
| 8 | Curlin | 203 | 98 | — | 48% | $12,907,617 |
| 9 | Not This Time | 193 | 121 | — | 63% | $12,387,349 |
| 10 | Quality Road | 214 | 97 | — | 45% | $11,590,102 |
| 11 | Good Magic | 165 | 92 | — | 56% | $10,900,872 |
| 12 | Goldencents | 361 | 184 | — | 51% | $10,347,708 |
| 13 | Nyquist | 224 | 112 | — | 50% | $10,269,420 |
| 14 | Arrogate | 140 | 76 | — | 54% | $10,018,963 |
| 15 | Hard Spun | 252 | 122 | — | 48% | $9,807,482 |
| 16 | Favorite Cartel | 375 | 181 | — | 48% | $9,529,267 |
| 17 | Kantharos | 267 | 158 | — | 59% | $9,419,691 |
| 18 | Mendelssohn | 261 | 135 | — | 52% | $9,268,032 |
| 19 | City of Light | 156 | 82 | — | 53% | $9,130,751 |
| 20 | Justify | 160 | 73 | — | 46% | $9,115,356 |
| 21 | Street Sense | 233 | 117 | — | 50% | $9,095,795 |
| 22 | Medaglia d'Oro | 132 | 74 | — | 56% | $8,933,573 |
| 23 | Liam's Map | 220 | 124 | — | 56% | $8,922,526 |
| 24 | American Pharoah | 200 | 95 | — | 48% | $8,768,685 |
| 25 | Oscar Performance | 114 | 69 | — | 61% | $8,764,077 |